Lake Alice aka Lake Tomahawk – USA, 2017 – reviews

‘Evil lurks beneath the surface’

Lake Alice – aka Lake Tomahawk – is a 2017 American horror film co-produced and directed by Ben Milliken, making his feature debut, from a screenplay by Stevie Jane Miller. It stars Caroline Tudor, Brad Schmidt, Brando Eaton, Laura Niemi and Peter O’Brien.


Meeting the Thomas family for the first time, Ryan Emerson (Brad Schmidt) must prove his intentions with their daughter, Sarah (Caroline Tudor), and win the approval of her father, Greg (Peter O’Brien), while he masks his jealousy for Sarah’s ex-fling, Tyler (Brando Eaton).

As the Thomases settles in, things start to happen around the cabin: strange footprints by the windows, noises from outside, and a bitter animosity from the locals, including the law enforcement.

As a blizzard descends on Lake Alice, so does the evil, as the family members are hunted down one by one. They struggles to stay alive as their power in numbers slowly dwindle…


“With a final reveal that turns eye-rolling into an Olympic sport, Lake Tomahawk heads into the final stretch with a deeply disappointing ending and a litany of unresolved threads. It’s by no means a lost cause, as with a fine cast of recognisable faces it’s still a pacey Yuletide tale, but just quell any enthusiasm before the inevitable downer hits you with all its might.” Dave Wain, The Schlock Pit

“Silly character motivations, bad horror movie cliches, people who turn out to be psycho for no apparent reason, cringe-worthy acting. It’s all there, and it’s all bad. Whatever goodwill the movie built up with its unique pacing is destroyed in the final five minutes. Still, everything up until the ending is done well enough, and I had fun watching the flick.” Patrick King, Cultured Vultures

“Able acting takes a slim script as far as it can go too. There’s just no getting around the lethargic lack of zip sucking the life out of everything. An ending that spins itself dizzy from several far-fetched switcheroos confirms Lake Alice relies too much on its silly surprise destination instead of fulfilling a satisfying journey of suspense.” Ian Sedensky, Culture Crypt

“You can’t set a movie like this up much better than Milliken manages. The problems however, begin to take shape after all of the introductory and exploratory work has reached its end. It’s when the violence gets to barreling along that some errors start to poke through the surface.” Matt Molgaard, Addicted to Horror Movies

“Unfortunately, the film seems to just switch on to autopilot at the third act (the film is just under eighty minute so the viewer is not waiting that long for something to happen) with dead phones, missing car keys, power outages, and a The Strangers-esque masked killer murdering his way through several of the red herrings…” Eric Cotenas, DVD Beaver

“It is weird to see how poorly handled all of the slasher elements are. The build up, the suspense, it is all gone, while the movie was still doing such a great job with this in its first half. Even the gore and kills feel terribly disappointing, as does the big ‘reveal’ at the end.” Frank Veenstra, Boba_Fett1138

“The film runs a swift 75 minutes; and thank god it does. Those early moments, where nothing much happens bar some drawn out familial scenes, are hard going. Add to that a number of audio issues […] and Lake Tomahawk certainly tries its damnedest to put the audience off the film at each and every turn.” Phil Wheat, Nerdly

Main cast:

  • Brando Eaton – Some Kind of Hate; Cabin Fever 3; American Horror Story
  • Laura Niemi – Chastity Bites
  • Peter O’Brien
  • Michael Shamus Wiles
  • Craig Rees
  • Eileen Dietz
  • Caroline Tudor
  • Brad Schmidt
  • Patrick Burch


The film was released on DVD in the UK on 8 May 2017 as Lake Tomahawk by High Fliers Films.

Filming locations:

Lake Alice, Tomahawk, Wisconsin, USA

MOVIES & MANIA is wholly independent and we rely solely on the very minor income generated by affiliate links and internet ads to stay online. Please support us by buying via Amazon links and not blocking ads on our site. Thank you, we appreciate it.

Quick links to contents:

A | B | C | D | E  | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

One Comment on “Lake Alice aka Lake Tomahawk – USA, 2017 – reviews”

Leave your comment here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.